MULTI-CRITERIA ASSESSMENT METHODS FOR THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PROTECTIVE STRUCTURES IN EMERGENCY SITUATIONS

Authors

  • L.A. Kamolov,S.Q. Jumayev,D.K. Nasriddinov PhD, Professor Academy of the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Uzbekistan Author

Keywords:

emergency situation, protective structure, multi-criteria assessment, integrated score, weight coefficient, evacuation, engineering support, inclusiveness, sustainability.

Abstract

This article examines the assessment of the effectiveness of protective structures used in emergency situations not on the basis of a single technical indicator, but on the basis of a set of interrelated criteria such as structural strength, capacity, engineering support, evacuation convenience, readiness for management, sanitary and hygienic condition, inclusiveness, and operational sustainability. Based on an analysis of the regulatory and legal documents of the Republic of Uzbekistan in the field of civil protection and protection from emergencies, international practical recommendations, and scientific sources, a multi-criteria assessment model consisting of eight blocks for protective structures was proposed. The model includes weight coefficients, standardization rules, threshold criteria, and an integrated rating method. In addition, sensitivity analysis was carried out using the example of three conditional facilities under a baseline scenario, a safety-priority scenario, and an access-and-egress-priority scenario. The results showed that structures with higher safety and accessibility may not always be inferior to facilities with larger capacity, while management and engineering systems significantly affect the stability of the final score. The proposed approach has practical significance for inventorying protective structures, determining repair priorities, comparing territorial needs, and increasing the level of preparedness for emergencies.

References

1. Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On Civil Protection.” May 26, 2000, No. 80-II. Lex.uz.

2. Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On the Protection of the Population and Territories from Natural and Technogenic Emergencies.” August 17, 2022, No. ORQ-790. Lex.uz.

3. Regulation on the State System for the Prevention of Emergencies and Action in Such Situations, approved by Resolution No. 515 of the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan dated August 26, 2020. Lex.uz.

5. United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction. Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030. Geneva, 2015.

6. United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction. Disaster Resilience Scorecard for Cities. Materials of the Making Cities Resilient 2030 platform.

7. World Health Organization. Hospital Safety Index: Guide for Evaluators. 2nd ed. Geneva, 2015.

8. Sphere Association. The Sphere Handbook: Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards in Humanitarian Response. Geneva, 2018.

9. Nappi M.M.L., Nappi V., Souza J.C. Multi-criteria decision model for the selection and location of temporary shelters in disaster management. Journal of International Humanitarian Action, 2019.

10. Godschall S., Brokopp Binder A., Hammond M., et al. A Decision Process for Optimizing Multi-Hazard Shelter Location Using Global Data. Sustainability, 2020.

11. Xu J., Yin X., Chen D., An J., Nie G. Multi-criteria location model of earthquake evacuation shelters to aid in urban planning. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2016.

12. Yu J., Wen J. Multi-criteria Satisfaction Assessment of the Spatial Distribution of Urban Emergency Shelters Based on High-Precision Population Estimation. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2016.

13. Alam M.D.J., Habib M.A., Hossain M.S., et al. Shelter locations in evacuation: A Multiple Criteria Decision Making approach. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2021.

14. Bera S., Saha S., Ghosh S., et al. Assessment of shelter location-allocation for multi-hazard emergency evacuation. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2023.

15. Atmaca E., Akyüz M., et al. Evaluated Post-Disaster and Emergency Assembly Areas Using Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Techniques: A Case Study of Turkey. Sustainability, 2023.

16. United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction. Annex for the inclusion of persons with disabilities in the Disaster Resilience Scorecard for Cities. 2022.

17. Federal Emergency Management Agency. Safe Rooms for Tornadoes and Hurricanes. FEMA P-361. Washington, official resources related to the 2025 edition.

18. U.S. Department of Justice. ADA Checklist for Emergency Shelters. 2007.

Downloads

Published

2026-05-18