From Catastrophe to Institution: War, Famine and the Collapse of Traditional Welfare as Preconditions for Child Protection in Turkestan, 1917–1921
Keywords:
Turkestan; famine; civil war; homeless children; Ferghana Valley; depopulation; child refugees; early Soviet welfareAbstract
The institutions created in the Turkestan Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (Turkestan ASSR) for homeless and neglected children—orphanages, children’s commissions, reception points, labour communes—were not the product of an abstract welfare programme. They were an emergency response to a convergence of catastrophes between 1917 and 1921: the collapse of political order and the violent suppression of the Kokand autonomy, a prolonged civil conflict in the Ferghana Valley, the severing of the cotton-for-grain economy that tied Turkestan to central Russia, repeated local famines, and, from 1921, the arrival of thousands of child refugees from the Volga region and the Kazakh steppe. This article reconstructs these causal chains on the basis of archival documents, the contemporary press and the secondary literature, and argues that the decisive factor was an “institutional vacuum”: the pre-revolutionary system of mutual help, based on waqf endowments, neighbourhood solidarity and kinship, proved unable to cope with a crisis of this magnitude, while the Soviet system was not yet formed. The article also shows that the composition of the child population in need—heavily marked by displacement, age and ethnic difference—shaped the first institutional responses, which relied to a surprising extent on placing children in families rather than in institutions.
References
1.Buttino, M. (1990). Study of the economic crisis and depopulation in Turkestan, 1917–1920. Central Asian Survey, 9(4), 59–74.
2.Cameron, S. (2018). The Hungry Steppe: Famine, Violence, and the Making of Soviet Kazakhstan. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
3.Khalid, A. (n.d.). Turkestan v 1917–1922 godakh: Borba za vlast na okraine Rossii [Turkestan in 1917–1922: The struggle for power on the periphery of Russia]. shosh.uz. (In Russian)
4.Mamadaliev, Sh. (2023). Coverage of famine and starving children in the press (1917–1924). International Journal on Integrated Education, 6(12), 277–291.
5.Saktaganova, Z. G., & Karsakova, G. B. (2017). Vliyanie goloda na rost chisla besprizornykh detei v Akmolinskoi gubernii v 1920-e gg. [The influence of famine on the growth of homeless children in Akmola province in the 1920s]. Vestnik KazNU, Seriya istoricheskaya, 3(86), 5–9. (In Russian)
6.Usmanov, F. A. (2022). Ўзбекистонда болалар қаровсизлиги масаласи (1917–1945 йиллар) [The problem of child neglect in Uzbekistan, 1917–1945] (PhD dissertation abstract). Termez. (In Uzbek)
7.Rasulov, A. N. (2016). Turkiston va Rossiya xalqlari o‘rtasidagi munosabatlar [Relations between the peoples of Turkestan and Russia]. Tashkent: Turon-Iqbol. (In Uzbek)
8.Rakhmatov, M. G. (2019). Turkistondagi ocharchilik va uning oqibatlari (1917–1924 yy.) [Famine in Turkestan and its consequences, 1917–1924] (PhD dissertation). Tashkent. (In Uzbek)
9.Rajabboev, N. A. (2020). Sovet hokimiyatining Turkistondagi oziq-ovqat siyosati va uning oqibatlari (1917–1924 yy.) [Soviet food policy in Turkestan and its consequences, 1917–1924] (PhD dissertation abstract). Tashkent. (In Uzbek)
10.Lyublinsky, P. I., & Kopelyanskaya, S. E. (1924). Okhrana detstva i borba s besprizornostyu [Protection of childhood and the struggle against homelessness]. Leningrad: Academia. (In Russian)
11.Savelyev, A. N., & Kostina, E. Yu. (n.d.). Problema detskoi besprizornosti v SSSR v 20–30 gody [The problem of child homelessness in the USSR in the 1920s–1930s]. Nauchnye issledovaniya i razrabotki molodykh uchenykh, 114–116. (In Russian)
12.Lukashina, V. (2019, September 2). Deti Grazhdanskoi voiny: Besprizorniki 1920-kh godov [Children of the Civil War: The homeless children of the 1920s]. vatnikstan.ru. (In Russian)
13.Kaipbaeva, A. T., Kozybaeva, M. M., Mukhatova, O. Kh., Baizhumanova, Z. B., & Bekenova, A. A. (Comps.). (2025). Iz istorii borby s detskoi besprizornostyu v Kazakhstane i sopredelnykh stranakh v 1920–1930-e gg. [From the history of the struggle against child homelessness in Kazakhstan and neighbouring countries in the 1920s–1930s]. Almaty: Balausa. (In Russian)
14.National Archive of Uzbekistan (NAU), f. R-95, op. 1, d. 531, l. 5.
15.NAU, f. R-25, op. 1, d. 682, l. 600.
16.NAU, f. R-17, op. 1, d. 398, ll. 1–3; f. R-34, op. 1, d. 1633, l. 27.
17.Izvestiya, December 1919; Izvestiya, 11 December 1921.




United Kingdom
Germany
France
Uzbekistan
Türkiye
Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Turkmenistan
Azerbaijan
India
Republic of Korea
Japan
United States of America
Kosovo
Italy
Spain
Poland
Netherlands
Belgium
Sweden
Norway
Finland
Denmark
Switzerland
Austria
Czech Republic
Hungary
Romania
Bulgaria
Greece
Portugal